Y-BOX: An evidence informed framework for engaging young men around the themes of violence and masculinities
Violence is highly prevalent. It is the single most experienced trauma for young people in Northern Ireland, and young men are at elevated risk of victimisation and perpetration. Socially and culturally, young men are often predisposed to a limited code of behaviour that endorses violence and neutralises the harms caused to victims.
They are at elevated risk of perpetrating violence against others, and this can take many forms. Central to the most effective models is an intentional focus on masculinity in what is broadly defined as gender conscious or ‘gender transformative’ approaches. Most gender transformative models have been applied in schools rather than in community settings. This poses several challenges.
Youth workers are uniquely positioned in the community to create a safe space for young men to engage in sensitive issues and themes such as masculinity and violence. Further, youth work approaches can help young men connect to the wider communities to engage in pro-social activities and practice non-violent skills.
In 2021, Queen’s University Belfast (QUB) partnered with the Education Authority of Northern Ireland (EANI) to examine the research and practice-based evidence around engaging and supporting young men across the themes of masculinity and violence. The strategic aim of the project was to increase the capacity of youth services to embed research into service design by combining cutting-edge empirical and theoretical evidence alongside practical approaches. Together, a framework called Y-Box was co-produced and then tested. Findings suggest changes in attitude as well as behaviour.
The Y-Box is an empirically supported framework for reducing violence among young men. The target group are young men aged 12-21. The participants engage in the framework on a voluntary basis in line with youth work principles and the model is intended to be delivered in the community by qualified youth workers/practitioners.
The aim of this evidence informed and co-produced intervention protocol is to provide a framework for youth workers to engage with young men around the theme of masculinity and violence.
The Y-Box is premised upon the idea that:
“By creating safe spaces for young men to critically reflect on the gender and behavioural norms that influence their social lives, they can understand their complex relationship with violence, as well as their responses to violence, and test feasible, non-violent alternatives.”
The aim of the framework and the resource is to increase the capacity of practitioners to positively and constructively engage boys and young men around the issues masculinity and violence.
The objectives of the intervention protocol are to provide preliminary evidence of the effectiveness of the intervention on transforming male gender norms and violence related outcomes.
- Young men aged 12-21
- Voluntary engagement
- Community based
- At risk of violence as a victim and/or as a perpetrator
- Primary (Universal)- This can be delivered with all young men
- Secondary (targeted) – This can be delivered with targeted groups of young men
During the design process, a theory of change was formulated. This theory of change summarises in a few words how we believe the model can meaningfully contribute towards violence reduction among young men. The statement below reflects this theory of change and figure 1 illustrates this.![]()
It is recommended that before delivering the model, youth workers/practitioners:
- Complete the training programme (see contact details below)
- Consult with the resource pack
- Agree a suitable evaluation framework
When ready to deliver, the intervention includes three core delivery components, and three facilitator components.
The delivery components include a process of (1) gender conscious engagement and reflection; (2) skills development, practice and rehearsal and; (3) opportunities for young men to engage as leaders in their own communities. See diagrams below:
EA Youth and QUB are delivering Y-BOX Training to Youth Workers and other practitioners across Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. This space is primarily to promote the Y-BOX Framework and provide a space for the practitioners access resources.
If you are interested in the training and seek further information on Y-Box please contact leigh.whittley@eani.org.uk
Anticipated Outcomes
A series of primary and secondary outcomes are envisaged:
PRIMARY: Increase in gender equitable attitudes (Conformity to masculine norms inventory).
SECONDARY: Reduction in incidences of exposure to violence (Exposure to Violence Scale and Likelihood of violence and delinquency scale).
Knowledge | 1. Increased understanding of general, specific and personal male gender and behavioural norms | 2. Increased understanding of the impact of harmful gender and social norms on violent behaviours | 3. Increased understanding of the impact of exposure to violence on mental health and wellbeing |
Values and beliefs | 1. Reduced adherence to and endorsement of traditional masculine norms | 2. Reduced acceptance of the values that endorse violence and aggression | 3. Increased endorsement of pro-social values |
Skills and behaviours | 1. Increased capacity to critically reflect thoughts/feelings and behaviours | 2. Reduction in exposure to violence | 3. Reduction in risk taking and potentially criminal behaviours |
Y-BOX Programme Library
Upon completing the Y-Box training, support will be provided. This may take the form of mentoring, coaching and/or a practice group.
Included in this section is some reading material, resource ideas to support delivery, links to other organisations and web pages, templates for delivery.